How Aaron Judge’s batting average compares to best in MLB history

https://library.sportingnews.com/styles/crop_style_16_9_desktop_webp/s3/2025-05/Aaron%20Judge.jpg.webp?itok=lOr-6lAJ
image

It was only a few years ago when Aaron Judge set an American League record for home runs in a season, and now he seems to have his eyes set on a different historic mark.

The Yankees slugger has gotten off to a blistering start in the first third of the MLB season, which is highlighted by a sky-high batting average. For most of the year, Judge has hit at or above the .400 mark, an incredible accomplishment for a player known for his power at the plate.

It’s hard to imagine Aaron Judge improving on his second MVP season in 2024, but that may have happened this year. The outfielder has cut down on his strikeouts to try to collect more hits, but he still is among the league leaders in home runs despite the changes.

So, what kind of history could Judge make if he keeps this up? Here’s a breakdown.

📲 Follow The Sporting News on WhatsApp

Aaron Judge batting average

Aaron Judge enters the series vs. the Dodgers with a .391 batting average, which leads all players this year.

It’s rare for a player to even approach hitting .400 in a season, but Judge may contend for the mark if he keeps this up. The two-time MVP has seemingly tweaked his approach at the plate to try and cut down on strikeouts, as his strikeout rate is currently at a career-best number.

MORE: How long is Alex Bregman out? Latest updates on Red Sox star’s quad injury

Has anyone batted .400 in a season?

In MLB seasons specifically, 13 players have batted .400 in a single campaign, and the last person to do it was Ted Williams with the Red Sox in 1941. That year, Williams batted .406, which is the eighth-best single-season batting average of all-time.

Here’s a look at every MLB player who has reached the .400 batting average mark in a season:

Year Name Team Batting Average
1901 Nap Lajoie Philadelphia Athletics .426
1924 Rogers Hornsby St. Louis Cardinals .424
1911 Ty Cobb Detroit Tigers .420
1922 George Sisler St. Louis Browns .420
1912 Ty Cobb Detroit Tigers .409
1911 Joe Jackson Cleveland Naps  .408
1920 George Sisler St. Louis Browns .407
1941 Ted Williams Boston Red Sox .406
1923 Harry Heilmann Detroit Tigers .403
1925 Rogers Hornsby St. Louis Cardinals .403
1922 Ty Cobb Detroit Tigers .401
1922 Rogers Hornsby St. Louis Cardinals .401
1930 Bill Terry New York Giants .401

Including the Negro Leagues, however, there have been 58 players to bat .400, but no one has done it since the 1948 Negro League season.

Most recently, the player who has come closest to hitting the .400 mark is Tony Gwynn. The Padres outfielder hit .394 in the strike-shortened 1994 season in what is still the highest batting average by a single player since 1980.

More: Shohei Ohtani takes big step toward pitching again

What is the highest single-season batting average ever?

The highest single-season batting average in MLB history belongs to Nap Lajoie, who hit .426 in 1901 while playing for the Philadelphia Athletic.

However, in the Negro Leagues, there were 12 different times in which a player had a higher batting average than Lajoie’s .426 mark, which is highlighted by Tetelo Vargas’ Negro League record of a .471 batting average in 1943. Vargas did that in just 136 plate appearances, whereas Lajoie’s MLB record came with 582 plate appearances.

SN’s MLB HQ: Live MLB scores | Updated MLB standings | Full MLB schedule

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.